Find out how to apply it to the art that you want to study, whether its photography, music, film, sculpture. The two traditional opposing positions taken with respect. This groundbreaking work begins with a thorough examination of the historical roots of the concept of ethical criticism as it applies to literature, the visual arts, and music. Pdf ethical criticism and the interpretation of art ted nannicelli. Ethicism is the thesis that the ethical assessment of attitudes manifested by works of art is a legitimate aspect of the aesthetic evaluation of those works, such that, if a work manifests ethically reprehensible attitudes, it is. The development of literary criticism as an autonomous discourse, separate and distinct from philology, history or philosophy, with its own practices, ideals and structure, is the key to understanding why ethical concerns are central to criticism in the angloamerican world. Moral principles and moral judgement introduction over the last two decades traditional, principlebased moral theories have come under. Reflects the importance of a moral life of engagement with works of art. Choice garry hagbergs new anthology art and ethical criticism consists of twelve new essaysten by philosophers, one each by an art historian and a professor of french. For many years ive led a discussion group called everyday ethics where people come to discuss an ethical. The article explores how a number of artists have employed the counteractual as a form of pasttalk in a conscious intervention into sociopolitical and ethical issues arising from the israeli occupation of palestine. Ethical criticism can never be simple, states, more challenging efforts to. The ethical criticism of art sites at lafayette lafayette college.
Drawing from these incidents and precedents, an ethical turn in art criticism might mean redefining the role of a critic to function more as participantobserver, a facilitator, or even a griot, with critical duties shared or handed over to participants. Art, ethical criticism of internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Gaut ethical criticism of art the ethical criticism of. Kieran ed, aesthetics and the philosophy of art oxford. Design, context, and meaning offers a comprehensive introduction to the world of art. The study examines public school programs that try to provide balanced instruction in art criticism, art history, and art production. Subjectivity in art history and art criticism eleni gemtou university of athens, greece abstract art history and art criticism belong in a wider sense to the humanities, whose aim is the interpretation and comprehension of human actions and intellectual work. Ottaway professor of philosophy and aesthetics at bard college, and in recent years has held a chair in the school of philosophy at the. I suppose it would have been some time in 1998 that i was contacted to contribute to a festschrift for art efron, one of my teachers in the. The art of george eliot in silas marner jstor i have taken silas marner as the book in which to study the art of its author because she may even criticize them, but the criticism is kindly meant.
Posner, against ethical criticism, 21 philosophy and literature 1 1997. Eisner, robert stake, brent wilson, marjorie wilson, milbrey wallin mclaughlin, margaret ann thomas. Noel carroll 2002 journal of aesthetics and art criticism 60 1. Values of art and the ethical question the british journal. Forms part of the prestigious new directions in aesthetics series, which confronts the most intriguing problems in aesthetics and the philosophy of art today. The ethical criticism of street art mary beth willard 0 0 weber state university to the person unfamiliar with the wide variety of street art, the term street artist conjures a young man furtively sneaking around a decaying city block at night, spray paint in hand, defacing concrete structures, ears pricked for police sirens. Moderate comic immoralism and the genetic approach to the ethical criticism of art. Both fields draw their basic methodological tools from the hermeneutical tradition. As the leader of the ethical humanist society for more than 30 years, people like irma have sought me out to talk about their moral quandaries. Art and ethical criticism new directions in aesthetics. An introduction to the philosophy of art by richard eldridge. An examination of art education in selected school districts, volume ii. Art and ethical criticism explores these elusive details to shine a scholarly light on the complex relationship between the arts and morality.
I argue that when conventionally interpreted as a request for a conce. Gaut ethical criticism of art the ethical criticism of art. Does a photographer who sells a portrait owe anything, financially or psychologically, to the works subject. Ironically, though the philosophy of art emerged initially as part and parcel of platos ethically motivated criticism of art, the ethical criticism. Summarizes the case reports and crosssite analysis of seven sites selected for a study of visual arts education. Pdf research has been extremely involved in improving in the art criticism area. Therefore, at this point i have shown that, on platos view, there are indeed experiences of beauty via art that produce good character. Moralists hold that art criticism can and should take stock of moral considerations. A persistent identifier can be found in the pdf version of this article.
Color texture color is light reflected off of an object. The ethical criticism of art chapter 7 aesthetics and ethics. Feldmans method there are many philosophies on how to analyses and interpreting art. Robert stecker 2008 journal of aesthetics and art criticism 66 2. This is why experiencing beautiful art is part of the proper education that prepares a person to live a moral life. Art and ethical criticism chicago journals the university of. The value of art cannot be ethical, because some great art has little or no ethical purpose consider purely abstract music. Though moralists disagree over the proper scope of ethical art criticism, they are unified in their acceptance of the consistency of valence thesis. The essay is a defense of ethical criticism, which is the view that the ethical dimensions of an artwork are relevant to its artistic value. Ethicism is the thesis that the ethical assessment of attitudes manifested by works of art is a legitimate aspect of the aesthetic evaluation of those works, such that, if a work manifests. Art and ethical criticism wiley online books wiley online library. Of course, despite the effective moratorium on ethical criticism in philosophical theories of art, the ethical evaluation of art. The scientific articles on art criticism article pdf available in asian social science 11. Its arguments have been with us for a long time, and its ends and means have been repeatedly anatomized by countless readers, sympathizers as well as.
R59 camera canon eos 5d mark ii externalidentifier urn. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Berys gaut 1993 journal of aesthetics and art criticism 51 4. Noel carroll 1993 journal of aesthetics and art criticism 51 2. Indeed, with regard to topics like racism, sexism, homophobia, and so on, it may even be the case today that the ethical discussion of art is the dominant approach on offer by. Daniel herwitz 2009 journal of aesthetics and art criticism 67 4. Martin kallich 1966 journal of aesthetics and art criticism 25 1. As far as i know no library in the world collects what galleries produce, with exceptions at the high end of the market.
It includes over 400 highquality images illustrating the history of art, its technical applications, and its many uses. The art of george eliot in silas marner jstor i have taken silas marner as the book in which to study the art of its author because she may even criticize them, but the criticism is. If there is a norm that a books title should give a reliable indication of its contents, art and ethical criticism does not quite meet it. This gap, moreover, is a recent one, since philosophers from plato through hume supposed that the pertinence of ethical criticism to art was unproblematic. Authored by four usg faculty members with advance degrees in the arts, this textbooks offers uptodate original scholarship. Jun 20, 2008 the selections are widely representative of approaches to ethical criticism of artworks, and the ethicalaesthetic dimensions of the literary, visual, and auditory arts.
On the one hand are those who advance ethicism, averring that the ethical criticism of. Values of art and the ethical question the british. Daily newspapers are collected by local and national libraries, but newspaper art criticism is not a subject term in any database i know, so art criticism. View ethical criticism research papers on academia. An introduction to the philosophy of art is a clear and compact survey of philosophical theories of the nature and value of art, including in its scope literature, painting, sculpture, music, dance, architecture, movies, conceptual art and performance art. This essay argues that the ethical criticism of art is a proper and legitimate aesthetic activity. Ethical evaluation of some genres is appropriate, but not of others.
On the one hand are those who advance ethicism, averring that the ethical criticism of art is a legitimate enterprise. In stecker and gracyk, aesthetics today 2010 this document is a summary of gaut. Against ethical criticism posner, richard a philosophy and literature. Ethical criticism and literary theory siobhan craft brownson in ethical criticism and liberal education. The ethical criticism of art berys gaut ethicism this essay argues that the ethical criticism of art is a proper and legitimate aesthetic activity. Fortunately, edmund feldman created a simple 4 step structure of the criticism of art consisting of description, analysis, interpretation and judgment. Two of the most noteworthy are that by joshua landy, an erudite, witty and sceptical analysis of the claim that good literature improves readers morally, and. Does the ethical value of a work of art ever contribute to its aesthetic value. My overall argument in this article is that a standard or typical form of judgment of an art works moral valuework w is morally flawed or morally meritorious. And ethical criticism of new work is still couched in old languagethat is, evaluation and judgment, as well as pernicious notions of quality and standards based on shared values, which many artists particularly those overlooked by institutional art history rightfully view with skepticism or disdain.
Berys gaut, the ethical criticism of art philpapers. The ethical criticism of art chapter 7 aesthetics and. Art and ethical criticism is a stimulating and insightful inquiry into contemporary philosophical debates that lie at the intersection of aesthetics and moral philosophy. This study attempts to discover 1 the factors that generate support for a strong, substantive art education program in a districts curriculum, and 2 what factors influence the willingness and ability of school districts and teachers to carry out and maintain a disciplinebased art education that strives for balance among the historical, critical, and productive domains of the visual arts. This book is a collection with a purpose, to bring analytical philosophers to the table of exploring numerous and wide.
Simon marcus december 2010 aesthetic criticism is divided on the admissibility of ethical claims in the correct analysis of art. Through a series of essays, art and ethical criticism explores the complex relationship between the arts and morality. Ethical criticism the art critical practice of considering a works ethical status or value in the assessment of its artistic worth is a practice as widespread as it is controversial amongst literary critics. Ethical criticism and the interpretation of art wiley online library. Ethical considerations t he consideration of ethics in research, and in general business for that. Since much current philosophical thought about the ethical criticism of the arts has taken shape against the background of those argumentsattempting either to. The article argues that debates about the ethical criticism of art have not acknowledged the fact that they are tacitly underpinned by a number of assumptions. Art criticism involves analyzing and evaluating every type of art that you can imagine. Ethical criticism refers to the inclusion of an ethical component in the interpretation and evaluation of art. Many universities have also developed guidelines for conducting ethical. Eros and experiences of beauty in platos theory of oral progress 33 this kind of influence. Samuel johnsons principles of criticism and imlacs dissertation upon poetry. Ethicism is the thesis that the ethical assessment of attitudes manifested by works of art is a legitimate aspect of the aesthetic evaluation of those works, such that, if a work manifests ethically reprehensible attitudes, it is to that extent.
482 175 429 1047 1308 1200 397 1156 934 1219 746 1092 1604 1550 837 720 546 1552 1060 391 398 569 1509 610 449 833 371 313 743 886 112 1347 935 774 584 1372 736 1620 106 1482 295 31 1093 1245 674 1091 1104 1023 794 1134 783